Question 1

What is a good cash-on-cash return for a vacation rental investment?

Accepted Answer

Most STR investors target a cash-on-cash return of 8–15%, though top-performing properties in high-demand markets can exceed 20%. The appropriate target depends on the investor's risk tolerance, financing costs, and alternative investment options. A 10% CoC return on a vacation rental compares favorably to the 4–6% typical of long-term residential rentals, but requires significantly more active management and carries higher vacancy and regulatory risk.

Question 2

How do I calculate cash-on-cash return for a short-term rental?

Accepted Answer

To calculate CoC return: subtract all operating expenses and annual mortgage payments from gross annual rental revenue to arrive at annual pre-tax cash flow, then divide by total cash invested (down payment plus closing costs plus any renovation or furnishing expenses) and multiply by 100. For example, a property generating $15,000 in annual cash flow after all expenses on a $150,000 cash investment yields a 10% CoC return. Including furnishing and startup costs in the denominator gives a more accurate picture than using the down payment alone.

Question 3

How does STR cash-on-cash return compare to long-term rental?

Accepted Answer

STR investments typically generate higher gross revenue than equivalent long-term rentals — often 2–3x more per year in strong markets — resulting in significantly higher CoC returns when occupancy is well-managed. However, STR operating costs are also substantially higher, including platform fees, professional cleaning, supplies, and furnishing replacement. The net advantage of STR over long-term rental is real but narrower than gross revenue comparisons suggest, and it comes with greater operational complexity and regulatory exposure.

Question 4

What factors most affect cash-on-cash return for vacation rentals?

Accepted Answer

The primary drivers of CoC return for STR investments are location demand and seasonality (which determine achievable ADR and occupancy), acquisition price and financing terms (which set the fixed cost baseline), operating expense management (particularly cleaning and maintenance), and pricing strategy (dynamic vs. static). Regulatory risk — the possibility of STR restrictions being enacted after purchase — is an often-overlooked factor that can materially impair returns by limiting operating days or forcing conversion to long-term rental.

Cash-on-Cash Return

Why this matters for property managers

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Terms

Related Guides